Singo furious over Broadcast Regulator’s ruling on Alan Jones - National Mass Media

Singo furious over Broadcast Regulator’s ruling on Alan Jones
by barra Wednesday, Apr 11 2007, 10:36pm
national / mass media / commentary

Life on the receiving end!

John Singleton, majority shareholder in the Macquarie radio network, hasn’t stopped bemoaning the decision of the regulator against flagship 2GB and talkback host/demagogue Alan Jones, since it released its findings.

"Do you think this results in sponsorships, advertising revenue or respect or increased reputation? No, no, no, this’ll cost us a tonne of money. People we were in the midst of merger negotiations with, will run [at] a hundred miles an hour."

"There is no punishment ... the punishment is what you're doing now, 2GB and Alan Jones being named as causing the riots.” [My poor bank account!] Singleton, an astute ad man, referred to the inevitable decrease in advertising revenue based on the perceived shift in the demographic of Jones’ listening audience, ".. value will be diminished because it will be seen as an audience of rednecks", he said. One wonders whether Singleton imagined Jones’ audience to be anything other than mindless morons and racists at any time.

The following is an excerpt from Michael Bodey's excellent article in the Australian, April 12, 2007:

"Of all our faults, Alan, (fellow 2GB broadcaster) Ray (Hadley), myself, you can agree or disagree but Jesus, not (accuse us of) intolerance," he said.

Macquarie Radio Network hired advisers Baron Partners in February to assess the network's future ahead of media reforms that have since come into force.

Mr Singleton holds a two-thirds stake in Macquarie, while Jones received 11.25 million options when the company floated in April 2005.

With an exercise price of 22.4c, and Macquarie's share price at $1.36, Jones is sitting on a paper profit in excess of $13 million if the publicly listed company were to be acquired or merge.

Mr Singleton said the most frustrating aspect of ACMA's ruling was the lack of recourse given the potential commercial implications.

"I'm told at first glance and second and third there is none, but if there is any we will be taking recourse because the commercial damage to 2GB, which is in the midst of publicly announced acquisition, merger and takeover discussions via Baron Partners, the commercial damage will be demonstrable, provable in the marketplace," he said. "If there is recourse for 2GB as a company, its directors and-or Alan Jones personally, we will be taking them, against either ACMA or their directors."

Macquarie's options against ACMA's findings are limited given it found the licensee breached only a code of practice, not a statute or law.

It can appeal in the Federal Court under the Administrative Decisions Judicial Review Act, but only on matters of process, not the merit of the decision.

This may be a likely course of action given 2GB's statement that ACMA's finding was "seriously flawed and ill-founded". The station continues to protest that complaints to ACMA were made only after Jones's comments were replayed by the ABC and other comments were erroneously attributed to him in The Sydney Morning Herald.

"If there's not (recourse), the question must be asked: What is ACMA doing, how many millions does it cost and what the fuck does it do?" Mr Singleton said.

Mr Singleton argued there should be an inquiry into ACMA "because I thought they were just sitting around bludging off the taxpayer not doing much".

The media authority was bound by its ongoing deliberation not to engage with Jones or Mr Singleton's criticisms.

But an ACMA spokesman said: "ACMA stands by its report and its media release of yesterday (Tuesday) and will now begin a process of discussing sanctions with 2GB."

Clearly, Mr Singleton has been personally affronted by ACMA's decision and subsequent reporting of it.

Rather than being seen to have merely breached commercial radio's code of practice, both Jones and 2GB have been pilloried as the essential causes of the Cronulla race riots in December 2005.

He said ACMA's ruling and its reporting was the most hurtful attack on Jones he had seen, worse than last year's publication of the biography by Chris Masters, Jonestown.

"The personal damage to Alan Jones is unbelievable, unbelievable," Mr Singleton said.

"This has been a lead story all day: 'Alan Jones starts race riots'. You've never known a more peaceable, tolerant human being in your life.

"He's also a very divisive personality, and he's very passionate in his views and very determined. I'm not sure of anything and Alan's sure of everything," he added.

"That's what makes him such a wonderful broadcaster, but nothing he's ever done deserves this.

"Forget what you think of Alan, forget what you think of his political views - I disagree with most of them - forget what you think of his coaching, whatever your personal views are, you cannot trash someone's individual reputation based on five letters from all around Australia, none of whom are from listeners, then ask Alan and 2GB to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to defend these letters, which we did, and then make a finding, to which there is no charge, to which there is no answer, to which there is no appeal as far as I understand at this stage. Fair go, fair go."

“Fair go”, ay! Is that what you gave people on the receiving end of Jones’ abuse and vilifying remarks? We can appreciate the pain in your hip-pocket nerve and the resulting agony you must be experiencing – how does it feel?

Copyright applies to quoted material.

War of the Jocks
by Sue Javes via strap - smh.com.au Thursday, Apr 12 2007, 11:55am

Talkback host John Laws enters the fray and 'serves it up' to the Prime Minister for his misplaced support of Alan Jones

SMH -- Talkback host John Laws has criticised Prime Minister John Howard for his "unflagging support" of rival Alan Jones, advising him to "read the book".

Laws, whose show's on 2UE, bought into the dispute between Jones and the broadcasting authority on his national program this morning, but his focus was the prime minister, not whether Jones had breached racial vilification laws or incited violence.

Mr Howard called Jones "an outstanding broadcaster" after the Australian Communication and Media Authority ruled Jones had breached the broadcasting code on his 2GB breakfast program in December 2005.

"It's not my place to say whether comments made by Alan were racist or not but what it does show is a prime minister who seems to be in trouble - big trouble," Laws told his listeners today.

"I mean if he feels he's got to keep Mr Jones on side because of the forthcoming election, I think he's got a problem."

In a reminder to the Prime Minister that Laws himself enjoys a national audience, he said: "Obviously the Prime Minister feels that he needs Mr Jones at the moment because things are looking shaky, and you do need a little support in Sydney but you'll get plenty of support in Sydney and that's all because Alan Jones only broadcasts in Sydney."

Laws also has a swipe at Janette Howard.

"Do you really want to be seen publicly supporting Alan Jones? I know you and your wife like him. That's fine, but your wife allegedly liked Peter Hollingworth too."

Referring to Chris Master's biography on Jones, Jonestown, Laws said: "Read the book Prime Minister.

"Then you better ask yourself if this is the sort of individual you want articulating what you seem to think are the views of many Australians.

"It's very easy to pander to prejudice. Many of the most dangerous people the world has ever known did just that."

© 2007 The Sydney Morning Herald

Topics

Other Press

Cleaves on Disc/Stick